Constructed operating decision / Allocation review
One pool. An explicit choice.
USD · Population shares, competing initiatives and retained commitments
Two pricing approaches have authored 60% and 40% shares. The 40% alternative is initially deferred because both do not fit the original capacity budgets. A later research revision chooses one competing policy for the full eligible cohort.
Capacity forces a bounded first wave
Trying both pricing packages blocks: pricing-review-targeted, pricing-gate-targeted. The modeled close therefore defers the alternative and leaves its 40% share unused. Resource budgets are unchanged.
Trace the decision
| Revision | Reason | Selected work | Year-one EBITDA | Year-one cash |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Preserve original constructed assumptions. | collections-timing, pricing-renewals, service-automation | 130,909 | 95,626 |
| 2 | Freeze capacity-tested hypothetical-close economics. | collections-timing, pricing-renewals, service-automation | 121,618 | 86,335 |
| 3 | Separate authored ownership-review challenge lowers base-case pricing capture to 50%; retained costs and capacity schedule remain explicit. This is not an estimate learned from three constructed accounting observations. | collections-timing, pricing-renewals, service-automation | 82,933 | 53,023 |
| 4 | Apply source rights, bounded terms and vendor commitments to each allocated population. | collections-timing, pricing-renewals, service-automation | -37,699 | -54,934 |
| 5 | Replace the authored pricing partition with one mutually exclusive alternative; do not reassign historical claims. | collections-timing, pricing-targeted, service-automation | -28,165 | -46,890 |
| 6 | Remove unsupported vendor release evidence and retain the adverse forecast for review. | collections-timing, pricing-targeted, service-automation | -163,165 | -181,890 |
One economic pool, explicit choices
Calculation selection: recorded policy. collections-timing; pricing-targeted; service-automation.
Recorded selection: collections-timing; pricing-targeted; service-automation. Research scenario selects pricing-targeted across the eligible cohort instead of two population partitions. This changes proposed scope; it does not move earlier claims or authorize customer actions.
A calculation override does not amend the recorded policy or authorize work. Save a reviewed case revision to record a different decision.
| Economic pool / rule | Member | Population share | Calculation scope | Owner / rationale / challenge |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| renewal-cohort / exclusive | pricing-renewals | 100.0% | Excluded | Proposed finance and commercial reviewers Authored redesign: two competing pricing policies on the same full cohort; implement at most one. Overlapping customer populations, unsupported rights or an unapproved intervention design. |
| renewal-cohort / exclusive | pricing-targeted | 100.0% | Selected | Proposed finance and commercial reviewers Authored redesign: two competing pricing policies on the same full cohort; implement at most one. Overlapping customer populations, unsupported rights or an unapproved intervention design. |
| support-vendor-spend / exclusive | service-automation | 100.0% | Selected | Proposed finance and commercial reviewers Authored population budget; customer identity and a company-approved split are unavailable. Overlapping customer populations, unsupported rights or an unapproved intervention design. |
| existing-receivables / exclusive | collections-timing | 100.0% | Selected | Proposed finance and commercial reviewers Authored population budget; customer identity and a company-approved split are unavailable. Overlapping customer populations, unsupported rights or an unapproved intervention design. |
Shares describe authored population scope. They are not probabilities or attribution of realized earnings.
Cost explanation: shared-foundation
Proposed finance and commercial reviewers: Equal explanatory cost shares across four candidates. The full committed posting survives exclusion; no causal attribution. Challenge: Overlapping customer populations, unsupported rights or an unapproved intervention design.
| Date | Owner | Component | Allocated amount |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-10-05 | collections-timing | implementation_expense | -6,250.00 |
| 2026-10-05 | pricing-renewals | implementation_expense | -6,250.00 |
| 2026-10-05 | pricing-targeted | implementation_expense | -6,250.00 |
| 2026-10-05 | service-automation | implementation_expense | -6,250.00 |
| 2026-10-05 | collections-timing | operating_cash | -6,250.00 |
| 2026-10-05 | pricing-renewals | operating_cash | -6,250.00 |
| 2026-10-05 | pricing-targeted | operating_cash | -6,250.00 |
| 2026-10-05 | service-automation | operating_cash | -6,250.00 |
Review the decision and its limits
Population shares do not allocate historical financial claims. A blocked or excluded share is not reassigned automatically. Shared commitments are posted once, with a separate explanation of ownership.
| Continuity check | Result |
|---|---|
| baseline | Preserved |
| observations | Preserved |
| attributions | Preserved |
Complete case history and accounting comparison · Current source constraints · Executive memo
Original allocation assumptions · Original capacity plan · Separate initiative split/merge exercise
This is a separate authored decision exercise. Its simulated reviews do not establish a company sponsor, independent finance validation, operating approval or real pilot outcomes.