Constructed operating decision / Allocation review
One pool. A traceable operating history.
USD · Population shares, competing initiatives and retained commitments
Two pricing approaches have authored 60% and 40% shares. The 40% alternative is initially deferred because both do not fit the original capacity budgets. A later research revision chooses one competing policy for the full eligible cohort.
Capacity forces a bounded first wave
Trying both pricing packages blocks: pricing-review-targeted, pricing-gate-targeted. The modeled close therefore defers the alternative and leaves its 40% share unused. Resource budgets are unchanged.
Trace the decision
| Revision | Reason | Selected work | Year-one EBITDA | Year-one cash |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Preserve original constructed assumptions. | collections-timing, pricing-renewals, service-automation | 130,909 | 95,626 |
| 2 | Freeze capacity-tested hypothetical-close economics. | collections-timing, pricing-renewals, service-automation | 121,618 | 86,335 |
| 3 | Separate authored ownership-review challenge lowers base-case pricing capture to 50%; retained costs and capacity schedule remain explicit. This is not an estimate learned from three constructed accounting observations. | collections-timing, pricing-renewals, service-automation | 82,933 | 53,023 |
| 4 | Apply source rights, bounded terms and vendor commitments to each allocated population. | collections-timing, pricing-renewals, service-automation | -37,699 | -54,934 |
| 5 | Replace the authored pricing partition with one mutually exclusive alternative; do not reassign historical claims. | collections-timing, pricing-targeted, service-automation | -28,165 | -46,890 |
| 6 | Remove unsupported vendor release evidence and retain the adverse forecast for review. | collections-timing, pricing-targeted, service-automation | -163,165 | -181,890 |
| 7 | Register exact full-pool KPI scopes and constructed January readings; aggregate only selected candidates. | collections-timing, pricing-targeted, service-automation | -163,165 | -181,890 |
| 8 | Explicitly revise pricing policy and KPI scopes to a 60% selected / 40% deferred partition; retain earlier full-pool observations. | collections-timing, pricing-targeted, service-automation | -172,699 | -189,934 |
| 9 | Change initiative identities with conserved pool shares and explicit task ancestry; require new scoped measurements. | collections-timing, pricing-wave-a, pricing-wave-b, service-automation | -172,699 | -189,934 |
| 10 | Record one child measurement; withhold the aggregate while the other child is unmeasured. | collections-timing, pricing-wave-a, pricing-wave-b, service-automation | -172,699 | -189,934 |
| 11 | Correct a prior reading, retain its old target and add independently authored current scoped measurements. | collections-timing, pricing-wave-a, pricing-wave-b, service-automation | -172,699 | -189,934 |
| 12 | Change initiative identities with conserved pool shares and explicit task ancestry; require new scoped measurements. | collections-timing, pricing-recombined, service-automation | -172,699 | -189,934 |
One economic pool, explicit choices
Calculation selection: recorded policy. collections-timing; pricing-recombined; service-automation.
Recorded selection: collections-timing; pricing-recombined; service-automation. Research scenario selects pricing-targeted across the eligible cohort instead of two population partitions. This changes proposed scope; it does not move earlier claims or authorize customer actions.
A calculation override does not amend the recorded policy or authorize work. Save a reviewed case revision to record a different decision.
| Economic pool / rule | Member | Population share | Calculation scope | Owner / rationale / challenge |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| renewal-cohort / partition | pricing-renewals | 40.0% | Excluded | Proposed finance and commercial reviewers Authored bounded rollout: 60% targeted scope, 40% competing approach deferred. This is a new policy, not a physical record split. Overlapping customer populations, unsupported rights or an unapproved intervention design. |
| renewal-cohort / partition | pricing-recombined | 60.0% | Selected | Proposed finance and commercial reviewers Authored bounded rollout: 60% targeted scope, 40% competing approach deferred. This is a new policy, not a physical record split. Overlapping customer populations, unsupported rights or an unapproved intervention design. |
| support-vendor-spend / exclusive | service-automation | 100.0% | Selected | Proposed finance and commercial reviewers Authored population budget; customer identity and a company-approved split are unavailable. Overlapping customer populations, unsupported rights or an unapproved intervention design. |
| existing-receivables / exclusive | collections-timing | 100.0% | Selected | Proposed finance and commercial reviewers Authored population budget; customer identity and a company-approved split are unavailable. Overlapping customer populations, unsupported rights or an unapproved intervention design. |
Shares describe authored population scope. They are not probabilities or attribution of realized earnings.
Cost explanation: shared-foundation
Proposed finance and commercial reviewers: Equal explanatory cost shares across four candidates. The full committed posting survives exclusion; no causal attribution. Challenge: Overlapping customer populations, unsupported rights or an unapproved intervention design.
| Date | Owner | Component | Allocated amount |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-10-05 | collections-timing | implementation_expense | -6,250.00 |
| 2026-10-05 | pricing-recombined | implementation_expense | -6,250.00 |
| 2026-10-05 | pricing-renewals | implementation_expense | -6,250.00 |
| 2026-10-05 | service-automation | implementation_expense | -6,250.00 |
| 2026-10-05 | collections-timing | operating_cash | -6,250.00 |
| 2026-10-05 | pricing-recombined | operating_cash | -6,250.00 |
| 2026-10-05 | pricing-renewals | operating_cash | -6,250.00 |
| 2026-10-05 | service-automation | operating_cash | -6,250.00 |
Change the plan. Preserve its measurement history.
The full-pool choice is subsequently narrowed to a 60% selected / 40% deferred partition. The selected 60% splits into 24% and 36% scopes, then recombines. Complete records stay in one economic pool. These are authored population fractions, not observed customer cohorts.
| Current KPI | Pool | Scope | Target | Current measurement |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| service-automation | support-vendor-spend | 100% | 90.00% | Constructed reading retained |
| collections-timing | existing-receivables | 100% | 90.00% | Constructed reading retained |
| pricing-recombined | renewal-cohort | 60.00% | 2.500% | Unavailable; needs a new scoped reading |
| Revision | Measurement period | Exact definitions | Scoped pricing result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 7 | 2027-01-01 | pricing-targeted-full-v1 | 2.00% |
| 10 | 2027-03-01 | pricing-wave-a-v1, pricing-wave-b-v1 | Withheld: missing current population |
| 11 | 2027-03-01 | pricing-wave-a-v2, pricing-wave-b-v1 | 3.40% |
Inspect identity and task ancestry
| Predecessor | Successor | Share of predecessor |
|---|---|---|
| pricing-targeted | pricing-wave-a | 40.0% |
| pricing-targeted | pricing-wave-b | 60.0% |
| pricing-wave-a | pricing-recombined | 100% |
| pricing-wave-b | pricing-recombined | 100% |
Monthly pool amounts follow the existing cent-rounding convention. Splits can change partial-period rounding and scheduled gate dates; financial comparisons retain those differences rather than claiming every daily amount is identical. Historical accounting and attribution remain on their frozen identities.
Review the decision and its limits
Population shares do not allocate historical financial claims. A blocked or excluded share is not reassigned automatically. Shared commitments are posted once, with a separate explanation of ownership.
| Continuity check | Result |
|---|---|
| baseline | Preserved |
| observations | Preserved |
| attributions | Preserved |
Complete case history and accounting comparison · Current source constraints · Executive memo
Original allocation assumptions · Original capacity plan · Separate initiative split/merge exercise
This is a separate authored decision exercise. Its simulated reviews do not establish a company sponsor, independent finance validation, operating approval or real pilot outcomes.